My son is a junior in high school, therefore will be attending his first prom next weekend. We went and got him fitted for a tuxedo – $100+ later – but I refused to pay the extra $28+ to just rent shoes. I knew I could find some shoes for about the same price that he could wear next year (hopefully if his feet don’t grow too much; he’s already a size 12) and even to church throughout the year. I ended up ordering these Men’s Zengara Z30028 classic formal wear patent leather oxfords for only $31.95 shipped! (Price is $34.95 – 10% off Coupon: SHOEBUY – code works on ANY order! Plus Free Shipping always!) Need shoes for a tux? Buy ‘em here!
[phpbay]tuxedo shoes, 2[/phpbay]

We’ll see how that works with your girls. I’m guessing you will not get away with buying only one pair for their prom and homecoming events.